Billy and Elizabeth started spending more and more time together, and before long, they were falling in love. Billy later said he was attracted to Elizabeth because she was smart, outspoken, and unlike other women he’d known. 

Things came to a head one night after a sold-out Attila show at a club in Amityville, Long Island. Jon was backstage drying his hair when he looked out the window and saw Billy talking to Elizabeth. Then, to his astonishment, Billy GOT INTO HER CAR AND DROVE AWAY WITH HER!